Monday, June 19, 2017

Major Management changes after Aegean Petroleum disappoints with signficant earnings shortfall


Aegean Petroleum (ANW) with its unusual business model compared to its bunker supplier peer competitors has been courting trouble for a long time that is finally beginning to roost on is management.  The company reported much worse than expected earnings for 1st Quarter 2017. Its CEO John Tavlarios resigned.  Neither Tavlarios - as director - nor Peter Georgiopoulos as Aegean Chairman garnered enough shareholder votes to continue on the Aegean Board of Directors.  Aegean announced that they want to move to an asset light business model, effectively throwing in the towel and following their competitors’ business model.  In my mind, it was a miracle that they were able to continue their previous course for so long in this brutal, overly competitive, low margin business.

I have been warning for years on Aegean and its weak and incoherent business strategy.  See my previous posts.  Aegean Marine Petroleum Network: lagging competitors with low return on investment and mounting financial expense eroding earnings margins http://amaliatank.blogspot.gr/2013/01/aegean-marine-petroleum-network-lagging.html.

The marine bunker business has the worst earnings margins in the fuel business.  The competition is brutal.  The normal course of most marine bunker companies is eventually to sell out to competitor companies.  Aegean stock price performance – always below NAV - has been crying out for years that its shareholders would be better served by this path given that a merger with an established competitor like World Fuel would offer them better value. 

Many of the peer companies are arms of major commodities traders such as the case of Chemoil that was acquired by Glencore.  Others like World Fuels (INT) are highly diversified in the fuel business in other more profitable areas like fuel for land trucking and jet aviation.  They are companies that have low leverage and are able to finance their sales with ample working capital. 

Aegean followed an inherently Greek strategy to build up assets and leveraged up in the process with debt.  Their IPO was to acquire an owned fleet of double hull bunker vessels and somehow gain competitive advantage with this delivery system. Never mind that marine bunker supply is a trading business and these assets are cost to them as part of their delivery system in their sales to customers, making this a ludicrous strategy for competitive advantage.   

Why Aegean attracted so many major value investors is something that I find inscrutable.  I have done consulting work on Aegean over the years for some of them and the experience was disconcerting.  I discovered the most incredible misconceptions about Aegean.  Many actually believed that Aegean with its bunker vessels was another Greek shipping company with tankers instead of a bunker supplier!!!! They were shocked when I tried to bring them to reality of the Aegean business model and explain to them how the bunker fuel business works. 

Several years later under the urging of Aegean’s founder, Mr. Melissanides, who had some land in Fujairah, Aegean embarked upon a strategy of building oil terminals for its bunker oil to be sold to customers.   

Now liquid storage for third parties as a business Is normally more profitable with better returns than selling bunker oil or even transporting oil for third parties, but this was to acquire the physical commodity and then sell it to its customers in competition with its peer competitors.  The logic was along the same lines as its fleet of bunker tankers.  Adding these assets to the balance sheet as well as the bunker fuel inventory required additional financing, for which Aegean increased its leverage and finance costs. 

By comparison, Glencore – a major trading company – upon acquiring Chemoil started to divest of Chemoil storage facilities to lighten up the balance sheet on the logic that rented space would be cheaper and more efficient.  Moreover, peer competitor companies generally avoid physical bunker commodity, preferring to purchase from producers like major oil companies and hedge their sales to customers with derivatives.   They all fostered an asset light business model to support their bunker trading business competitively given the very low margins on sales.  Concurrently, they wanted to keep finance costs to a minimum. 

Aegean actively bought market share as a growth strategy and raised additional capital to do so.  Over time, Aegean got more and more bogged down with a heavy asset based balance sheet and aimless expansion without a coherent strategy for competitive advantage and better earnings margins. 

Personally, I give enormous credit to John Tavlarios that he managed as well as he did to hold on for so long given the extensive challenges that he faced with such an unproductive business strategy against a lean, brutal competition.  But these dramatic events where Aegean now publicly want  themselves to move to a more asset light business model that they have finally seen the light and thrown the towel here. 

Agile low-cost newcomers are cropping up in their major fuel hubs.  The market is saturated with back to back trading entities.  Aegean is going to have to start selling off its assets, deleverage and consider potentially exiting less profitable markets. 

The biggest jack asses in this mess are Aegean’s two largest shareholders  Canada’s Senvest Management and US-based Towle & Co. who bought into Aegean and are the largest shareholders.  They should have realized years ago the incongruities in Aegean with its asset heavy approach.  The case speaks for itself!  Hopefully, they will work themselves out of this to create some value for their investors.  Despite the challenges, I believe that Aegean shareholders could see better days with the management in the right hands.


18 comments:

  1. Hello Friends I am Mahi Chopra Independent Mumbai Escorts girl offer High Profile Escorts Service in Mumbai 24/7 Avails for fantastic and Luxury moment to you

    Mumbai Escorts | Call Girls in Mumbai | Mumbai Call Girls | Escorts in Mumbai | Russian Mumbai Escorts | Call Girls Service in Mumbai | Escort Service in Mumbai

    ReplyDelete
  2. include everything premiere in our services.We feel delighted to have you onboard as our prestigious clients who are going to experience the extreme moments of lovemaking with our escorts.
    Dhaula Kuan Escorts Service #
    East Of Kailash Escorts Service #
    Greater Kailash Escorts Service #
    Indirapuram Escorts Service #
    Vasundhara Escorts Service #
    Janakpuri Escorts Service #
    Kalkaji Escorts Service #
    Kapashera Escorts Service #
    Lajpat Nagar Escorts Service #

    ReplyDelete
  3. We have set a standard of excellence for the Mumbai Call Girls business in India, and we have made significant contributions to make these adult entertainment services universal, and accessible to men from all walks of life.

    $$ Female Escorts In Mumbai
    $$ Female Escorts In Mumbai
    $$ Female Escorts In Mumbai
    $$ Female Escorts In Mumbai
    $$ Female Escorts In Mumbai
    $$ Female Escorts In Mumbai
    $$ Female Escorts In Mumbai
    $$ Female Escorts In Mumbai
    $$ Female Escorts In Mumbai

    ReplyDelete
  4. Escorts In Churchgate are really skill full and they are not just providing their services with in mumbai,they provide extended services to other cities in India.

    && Female Escorts Mumbai
    && Female Escorts Mumbai
    && Female Escorts Mumbai
    && Female Escorts Mumbai
    && Female Escorts Mumbai
    && Female Escorts Mumbai
    && Female Escorts Mumbai
    && Female Escorts Mumbai

    ReplyDelete
  5. Of course, Escorts In Delhi all of our escorts are vetted to the highest standard possible. We ensure that every Diva listed on our books is capable, versatile, flexible and of course, stunningly gorgeous.

    paschim vihar escorts ##
    aerocity escorts ##
    cr park escorts ##
    rk puram escorts ##
    rajouri garden escorts ##
    pashchim vihar escorts ##
    punjabi bagh escorts ##
    dwarka escorts ##
    connaught place escorts ##

    ReplyDelete

  6. If you are thinking to give it a shot with professional Dwarka Call Girls Service then you should be going for over other call girls in the industry. You are supposed to get so many amazing features and qualities.

    $$ Housewife Escorts In Laxmi nagar
    $$ Housewife Escorts In Mayur vihar
    $$ Housewife Escorts In Ashram
    $$ Housewife Escorts In Kalkaji
    $$ Housewife Escorts In Sarita vihar
    $$ Housewife Escorts In New friends colony
    $$ Housewife Escorts In Okhla
    $$ Housewife Escorts In Mukherjee nagar
    $$ Housewife Escorts In Mehrauli
    $$ Housewife Escorts In Jangpura

    ReplyDelete
  7. We basically deal with the high profile Noida Escorts who can fulfill all the requirements of the clients. So, all our past clients never see any other escorts agency because we know better our clients and their requirements.
    Escorts In Shakti Khand ##
    Escorts In Wave City ##
    Escorts In Tronica City ##
    Escorts In Dasna ##
    Escorts In Jaipuria Enclave ##
    Escorts In Pratap Vihar ##
    Escorts In Krishna Vihar ##
    Escorts In Shalimar Garden ##
    Escorts In Ramprastha ##

    ReplyDelete

  8. Those Russian Escort In Delhi can be reached directly via their website. You can hire those ladies for adult enjoyments as well for other purposes. You can hire those dashing ladies to enjoy your weekend at any nearby place where you can enjoy for a long time.

    $$ Independent Escorts Delhi
    $$ Vip Call Girls Delhi
    $$ Escorts In Delhi
    $$ Independent Escorts Chanakyapuri
    $$ Independent Escorts Connaught Place
    $$ Independent Escorts Defence Colony
    $$ Independent Escorts Dhaula Kuan
    $$ Independent Escorts Dwarka
    $$ Independent Escorts East Of Kailash

    ReplyDelete
  9. Call/Whatsapp+91- 9873777170 Delhi Escorts service & Delhi Erotic girls | Colege call girls service facility available. visit my blog:-
    Daryaganj Escorts &&
    Defence Colony Escorts &&
    Delhi Cantt Escorts &&
    Dhaula Kuan Escorts &&
    Nehru Place Escorts &&
    Malviya Nagar Escorts &&
    Saket Escorts &&

    ReplyDelete